Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Leanna's avatar

Wow--I identify with so many things you said in this post. I too was raised secular by a Jewish mom who was also raised secular--but both of our childhoods were steeped in cultural Jewishness. Like her, I married a goy and, though I gave my kids Jewish first names, I’m raising them in wisconsin without the tools to really pass our heritage on to them. I have Jewish imposter syndrome. But I’ve also read that not feeling “Jewish enough” is a fundamental part of being Jewish at all, ha. Anyway--not to blather on about my own admittedly big feelings about this--just wanted to say this resonated with me a lot. Chanukah sameach to you and yours!

Expand full comment
Ally's avatar

I celebrate Hanukkah lightly -- which today, at my in-laws, involved a tinfoil-and-birthday-candle menorah 🕎. I also have complicated feelings about being Jewish in the specific, not-enough ways that I am: a Jewish grandmother from New York who assimilated, married a catholic, and denounced religion entirely but served gefilte fish at parties and so many cultural signifiers that carried down to me. Now I light Shabbat candles on the occasional Friday night I can tell my atheist mom is worried I’m becoming religious (hah) but I just want to stay connected to this culture that is somehow part of me.

Thanks for sharing about your Jewish identity. Chag sameach and happy solstice ✨

Expand full comment
25 more comments...

No posts